Someone on the BalletTalk For Dancers forum posted a link to an article in the Los Angeles Times about Matthew Leonardi, a gifted 14-year old ballet dancer who was one of only three Americans accepted this year into the Bolshoi Ballet School. Best yet, Matthew is the only boy. Teenage boys in ballet are still a relative rarity in this country which, together with his Bolshoi acceptance, was what made the story newsworthy. To add to the drama, there is a chance that Matthew won’t be able to go due to financial reasons. According to the article, one year’s fees amount to $18K.
At first, the people at BT4D were congratulatory. Then, it degenerated. There was a post about his horrible feet, then some posts questioning his talent (this despite the fact that he was freaking ACCEPTED INTO THE BOLSHOI SCHOOL), and even more posts questioning his parents’ devotion of resources to him in light of the fact that he has siblings who also might need/want the money/his parents’ attention.
Then I opened my big mouth and wondered how I might be able to send a donation. I expressed my support for this rising American-born premier danseur and mentioned the fact that Ethan Stiefel himself has mentioned their rarity.
The floodgates of hate and negativity poured after that. A poster actually tried to make me feel guilty about donating only to Matthew and not to her daughter. Another poster tried to correct me by saying male ballet students are actually proliferating in the U.S. Yet another poster, after reading that donation checks should be made out to Matthew, said that she was uncomfortable giving directly to him because what if he changes his mind and doesn’t go to the Bolshoi School?
I couldn’t believe the amount of snark and negativity on a forum supposedly populated by balletomanes. I couldn’t believe someone actually had the pomposity to criticize Matthew’s talent after reading an article about his acceptance to the Bolshoi School. And so what if male dancers are proliferating in the U.S.? Does this mean I shouldn’t donate to Matthew? As for the poster who was uneasy about giving a donation directly to Matthew, then DON’T. No one is forcing anyone to donate to him. Matthew’s family wasn’t even soliciting on BT4D. If you are uncomfortable about the whole situation, keep your money. No one wants it.
My biggest shocker was how some BT4D posters were actually trying to make me feel bad for my desire to donate. Since when has philanthropy and generosity become a bad thing? I’ve never met a group more negative toward this boy and his accomplishments, and this from a group of supposed ballet supporters. I have received some positive private messages encouraging me to keep supporting boys in dance, mostly from mothers of boys. They’ve counterbalanced the negative messages somewhat, but I’ve decided to stay away from the vitriol and snark at BT4D. It’s a bad, bad place filled with people who have delusions of being ballet supporters but are in fact far from it.
